Who should've made the list? Who was ranked too high? Our college football experts give their thoughts on the preseason top 100 list.

Smith, Leonard Moore and Ryan Williams quickly established themselves as stars during elite freshman campaigns in 2024, but it's a nearly impossible task to predict which first-year players will break out in 2025.

Three Texas A&M stars unsurprisingly landed in ESPN top 100 college football player rankings, led by LB Taurean York at No. 58.